UPSC CSAT Comprehension – Chapter 14: Traps, Elimination and Option Analysis (25 MCQs)

← Back

UPSC CSAT Comprehension – Chapter 14: Traps, Elimination and Option Analysis (25 MCQs) – 21 questions, subject: CSAT Comprehension. Every question has the correct answer with a two-line explanation; tap "Show Answer". Free practice for TNPSC, UPSC, SSC, Bank and RRB exams – Shanmugam IAS Academy, Coimbatore.

Get daily current affairs & exam alerts – follow us YouTube WhatsApp Channel Telegram Channel Facebook Page Instagram
Share with friends & study groups
Link to this page from your website / blog (HTML code)
1.  

An option that is true in the world but absent from the passage is a trap of:

Correct Answer: A [outside fact]

Explanation:

An option that is true in the real world but is not stated or implied in the passage is an outside-fact trap. It must be rejected, because answers rest only on the passage, not on general knowledge.

2.  

"Interlinking of rivers across the country" in the 2022 flood-drought item is a:

Correct Answer: D [grand solution]

Explanation:

The 2022 passage only states the problem (too much water for about 120 days and too little for about 245), and the keyed answer, storing water and recharging aquifers, meets that need. Interlinking rivers across the country is a grand solution whose costs the passage never weighs.

3.  

In the order of elimination, partial truth is checked:

Correct Answer: D [last]

Explanation:

Partial truth is checked last, because it needs the surviving options to be compared against the whole passage. Outside facts, reversals and extreme words are easier to spot and are removed first.

4.  

A passage on cities answered with an option about the whole economy shows:

Correct Answer: D [scope shift]

Explanation:

Answering a passage about cities with an option about the whole economy widens the subject beyond the passage, which is a scope shift. A reversal would state the opposite of the passage, and an extreme word trap would use terms like "always" or "only".

5.  

Passage: "In the town, most bus passengers are students and daily workers, who travel at fixed hours in the morning and evening."

Which one of the following can most reasonably be inferred from the passage?

Correct Answer: B [Buses in the town are likely to be most crowded in the morning and evening.]

Explanation:

If most passengers are students and daily workers travelling at fixed morning and evening hours, buses are most likely to be crowded at those hours. The passage says nothing about private vehicles, fares or cycling, so those options rest on outside assumptions.

6.  

Passage: "Regular exercise lowers the risk of several common illnesses."

Which one of the following is supported by the passage?

Correct Answer: D [Regular exercise can reduce the chance of some illnesses.]

Explanation:

The passage says exercise lowers the risk of several common illnesses, so the supported statement is that regular exercise can reduce the chance of some illnesses. Words like "all", "will" and "only" in the other options make claims far stronger than the passage.

7.  

For the 2023 river-water item, the passage's own remedy is:

Correct Answer: D [a legal and policy framework for allocation]

Explanation:

The 2023 river-water passage calls for allocating water on objective, basin-based criteria, which needs a legal and policy framework for allocation. Linking all rivers or moving water from surplus to deficit regions are big projects the passage does not propose.

8.  

Consider the following statements:

1. A wrong CSAT option usually has a single small defect.
2. GS knowledge should be used to correct factual errors in a passage.
3. Between the last two options, coverage of the whole passage is a test.

Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

Correct Answer: B [1 and 3 only]

Explanation:

Statements 1 and 3 are correct: a wrong option usually fails on one small defect, and when two options survive, the one that covers the whole passage is preferred. Statement 2 is wrong because a passage must be read as written; general knowledge is not used to correct it.

9.  

Assertion (A): In practical-action items the biggest nationwide project is usually a wrong option.

Reason (R): The passage supports the remedy tied to its own diagnosis, not a larger project whose costs it never weighs.

Correct Answer: A [Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A]

Explanation:

Both are true and R explains A: the passage supports only the remedy tied to its own diagnosis, so a big nationwide project whose costs it never weighs is usually wrong. This is why the small, local fix is generally the right answer in practical-action items.

10.  

Passage: "In the district's government schools, attendance rose after the midday meals were served hot and freshly cooked."

Which one of the following is best supported by the passage?

Correct Answer: C [Freshly cooked meals were followed by better attendance in the district's government schools.]

Explanation:

Option (c) stays within the passage's subject, place and claim: in the district's government schools, attendance rose after meals were served hot and fresh. Options (a) and (b) overgeneralise to all schools or to learning outcomes, which the passage does not mention.

11.  

Passage: "Far from reducing the need for teachers, digital lessons work well only where a teacher guides the class through them."

Which one of the following is supported by the passage?

Correct Answer: B [Digital lessons depend on teachers to be effective.]

Explanation:

The passage says digital lessons work well only where a teacher guides the class, so they depend on teachers to be effective. Option (a) reverses the passage, and option (d) is an extreme claim it does not make.

12.  

Passage: "Burning crop residue pollutes the air of nearby cities, but farmers burn it because it is the cheapest way to clear the field quickly for the next crop. Unless a cheaper way of clearing is available, appeals alone will change little."

Which one of the following best reflects the most logical and practical message of the passage?

Correct Answer: C [Affordable alternatives are needed to reduce the burning of crop residue.]

Explanation:

The last line says appeals alone will change little unless a cheaper way of clearing the field is available, so affordable alternatives are needed. Option (b) is only a fact stated in the passage, not its main message, and option (a) blames farmers without support.

13.  

In the 2021 cyber passage, "Stringent data security laws are needed" fails because:

Correct Answer: C [no line of the passage discusses laws]

Explanation:

No sentence of the 2021 cyber passage mentions laws, so the option rests on outside knowledge and fails the line-pointer test. It is not wrong for being extreme or reversed; it is simply not supported by the passage.

14.  

"Practical, rational and immediate action" stems most often plant the trap of:

Correct Answer: A [grand solution]

Explanation:

Stems asking for practical, rational and immediate action tempt candidates towards big, sweeping projects, which is the grand-solution trap. The right answer is usually a small, direct remedy tied to the cause named in the passage.

15.  

Passage: "Several studies suggest that reading aloud to young children improves their vocabulary."

Which one of the following is NOT supported by the passage?

Correct Answer: A [Reading aloud is the only way to improve young children's vocabulary.]

Explanation:

Option (a) is not supported because the word "only" goes beyond the passage, which says reading aloud improves vocabulary but does not rule out other ways. Options (b), (c) and (d) stay within what "several studies suggest".

16.  

In a multi-statement item, a statement that is mostly right but has one wrong part should be:

Correct Answer: B [rejected]

Explanation:

A statement that has even one wrong part is false as a whole, so it must be rejected in a multi-statement item. Accepting a mostly right statement is a common partial-truth trap.

17.  
UPSC Prelims (CSAT) 2021

Passage: A social and physical environment riddled with poverty, inequities, unhygienic and insanitary conditions generate the risk of infectious diseases. Hygiene has different levels: personal, domestic and community hygiene. There is no doubt that personal cleanliness brings down the rate of infectious diseases. But the entry of the market into this domain has created a false sense of security that gets conditioned and reinforced by the onslaught of advertisements. Experience in Western Europe shows that along with personal hygiene, general improvements in environmental conditions and components like clean water, sanitation and food security have brought down infant/child death/infections rates considerably. The obsession with hand hygiene also brings in the persisting influence of the market on personal health, overriding or marginalizing the negative impact on ecology and the emergence of resistant germs.

On the basis of the passage given above, the following assumptions have been made:

1. People who are obsessed with personal hygiene tend to ignore the community hygiene.
2. Emergence of multi-drug resistant germs can be prevented by personal cleanliness.
3. Entry of the market in the domain of hygiene increases the risk of infectious diseases.
4. Scientific and micro-level interventions are not sufficient to bring down the burden of infectious diseases.
5. It is community hygiene implemented through public health measures that is really effective in the battle against infectious diseases.

Which of the above assumptions are valid?

Correct Answer: C [4 and 5 only]

Explanation:

Western Europe's experience shows that personal measures alone were not enough (assumption 4) and that clean water, sanitation and food security, that is community hygiene through public health, brought infections down (assumption 5). The passage says personal cleanliness cannot stop resistant germs, so assumption 2 is wrong (UPSC CSAT 2021).

18.  
UPSC Prelims (CSAT) 2021

Passage: Computers increasingly deal not just with abstract data like credit card details and databases, but also with the real world of physical objects and vulnerable human bodies. A modern car is a computer on wheels; an aeroplane is a computer on wings. The arrival of the "Internet of Things" will see computers baked into everything from road signs and MRI scanners to prosthetics and insulin pumps. There is little evidence that these gadgets will be any more trustworthy than their desktop counterparts. Hackers have already proved that they can take remote control of internet connected cars and pacemakers.

Which one of the following statements best reflects the most critical inference that can be made from the passage given above?

Correct Answer: A [Computers are not completely safe.]

Explanation:

The passage says there is little evidence that connected gadgets will be more trustworthy than desktops and that hackers have already taken control of cars and pacemakers, so computers are not completely safe. It does not discuss company attitudes or data security laws (UPSC CSAT 2021).

19.  
UPSC Prelims (CSAT) 2021

Passage: Our cities are extremely vulnerable to climate change because of large concentrations of populations and poor infrastructure. Moreover, population densities are increasing in them, but we have not yet developed the systems to address climate change impacts. Our cities contribute to 65 percent of the GDP, but there are not enough facilities to cater to the needs of the people. It is important to address the issues of air quality, transport, etc., that are vital to identifying sustainable solutions. We need to involve citizens in city planning and create an ecosystem that meets the needs of people.

Which among the following is the most logical and rational inference that can be made from the passage given above?

Correct Answer: C [To maintain and develop our cities we need to adopt sustainability related interventions.]

Explanation:

The passage links the vulnerability of cities to issues such as air quality, transport and citizen participation, all of which point to sustainability-related interventions. It does not discuss administrative autonomy or the PPP model, and it treats density as a fact, not as the main hindrance (UPSC CSAT 2021).

20.  
UPSC Prelims (CSAT) 2020

Passage: India has tremendous potential for solar energy. We all realize that we have to stop burning fossil fuels to meet our energy needs. But certain renewable resources are still going through their cost curves and learning curves to get the required amount of output. The Indian Government has strongly committed to its targets of reducing emissions by 33 per cent by 2030, and towards this, it has initiated a strong push towards a gas-based economy and has also invested heavily in renewable energy. However, business houses are wary of investing too heavily in renewable energy at a time when the technology is not yet ready.

Which one of the following is the most logical and rational inference that can be made from the above passage?

Correct Answer: C [Getting renewable resources to market too soon may be costly.]

Explanation:

The passage says some renewable technologies are still on their cost and learning curves and business houses fear investing before the technology is ready, so bringing them to market too soon may be costly. Nothing in it says the 33% target will fail or that gas should replace renewables (UPSC CSAT 2020).

21.  
UPSC Prelims (CSAT) 2023

Passage: We often hear about conflicts among different States in India over river waters. Of the 20 major river systems, 14 are already water-stressed; 75% of the population lives in water-stressed regions, a third of whom live in water-scarce areas. Climate change, the demands of rising population and the need for agriculture to keep pace, and increased rate of urbanization and industrialization will exacerbate water stress. According to the Constitution of India, water is a State subject and not that of the Union, except for regulation of inter-State rivers. Key to ensuring balance between competing demands of various stakeholders is a basin-based approach to allocate water amongst constituent regions and States. Allocating fair share of water to them requires assessments based on objective criteria, such as specificities of the river basin, size of dependent population, existing water use and demand, efficiency of use, projected future use, etc. while ensuring the environmental needs of the river and aquifers.

Which one of the following statements best reflects the most rational, practical and immediate action required to ensure fair and equitable allocation of water to different stakeholders?

Correct Answer: A [A national, pragmatic, legal and policy framework for water allocation should be made.]

Explanation:

basin-based allocation on objective criteria needs a legal and policy framework.

➤ Full notes, maps, tables, a reason for every option and Mains PYQs – U23 · CSAT Comprehension (UPSC book, ₹249): www.shanmugamiasacademy.in/study-materials/upsc-csat-comprehension

📘 U23 · CSAT – Comprehension and Interpersonal Skills – UPSC Civil Services (Prelims Paper II – CSAT)
Here you get the answer with a one-line explanation. 16 chapters · 463 questions incl. UPSC CSAT comprehension PYQs with a reason for every option · method for every question type · revision cards
Get the book – ₹249 ₹499 →
Score: 0 Answered: 0 / 0