UPSC Ethics, Integrity and Aptitude – Chapter 14: Ethical Dilemmas and Sources of Ethical Guidance – Laws, Rules, Regulations and Conscience (20 MCQs)

← Back

UPSC Ethics, Integrity and Aptitude – Chapter 14: Ethical Dilemmas and Sources of Ethical Guidance – Laws, Rules, Regulations and Conscience (20 MCQs) – 20 questions, subject: Ethics (GS-IV). Every question has the correct answer with a two-line explanation; tap "Show Answer". Free practice for TNPSC, UPSC, SSC, Bank and RRB exams – Shanmugam IAS Academy, Coimbatore.

Get daily current affairs & exam alerts – follow us YouTube WhatsApp Channel Telegram Channel Facebook Page Instagram
Share with friends & study groups
Link to this page from your website / blog (HTML code)
1.  

A situation in which each available option is backed by a moral reason is called an ethical:

Correct Answer: B [dilemma]

Explanation:

An ethical dilemma arises when every available option is backed by a moral reason, so choosing one means sacrificing another value. A temptation, in contrast, is a choice between right and wrong, where only one option is morally justified.

2.  

The four "right-versus-right" paradigms were described by:

Correct Answer: A [Rushworth Kidder]

Explanation:

Rushworth Kidder described four right-versus-right paradigms: truth versus loyalty, individual versus community, short term versus long term, and justice versus mercy. He set them out in his book 'How Good People Make Tough Choices' (1995).

3.  

Freedom of conscience is guaranteed by Article:

Correct Answer: C [25]

Explanation:

Article 25 guarantees freedom of conscience and the right to freely profess, practise and propagate religion, subject to public order, morality and health. Article 19 deals with freedom of speech and other freedoms, and Article 29 protects the cultural rights of minorities.

4.  

Choosing between accepting a bribe and staying honest is best described as:

Correct Answer: B [a test of integrity, not a true dilemma]

Explanation:

Bribe versus honesty is a choice between right and wrong, so it is a test of integrity or a temptation, not a true dilemma between two rights. A true ethical dilemma, by contrast, is a right-versus-right choice where each option is backed by a moral reason.

5.  

The essay "Resistance to Civil Government" (1849), later known as "Civil Disobedience", was written by:

Correct Answer: B [Henry David Thoreau]

Explanation:

Henry David Thoreau wrote 'Resistance to Civil Government' (1849), later called 'Civil Disobedience', after refusing to pay a tax that supported slavery and war. The essay influenced Gandhi and Martin Luther King Jr.

6.  

In Bijoe Emmanuel v. State of Kerala (1986), the Supreme Court protected:

Correct Answer: D [students who did not sing the national anthem on grounds of faith]

Explanation:

Bijoe Emmanuel v. State of Kerala (1986) protected Jehovah's Witness students who stood respectfully but did not sing the national anthem on grounds of faith. The Supreme Court held that their expulsion violated Articles 19(1)(a) and 25, as no law compels anyone to sing the anthem.

7.  

Satyendra Dubey, killed in 2003 after raising corruption issues, worked with the:

Correct Answer: D [National Highways Authority of India]

Explanation:

Satyendra Dubey, an engineer with the National Highways Authority of India (NHAI), was killed in 2003 after reporting corruption in the Golden Quadrilateral highway project. His death led to the Public Interest Disclosure and Protection of Informers (PIDPI) Resolution of 2004, a step towards the Whistle Blowers Protection Act, 2014.

8.  

Standards set by bodies such as SEBI and RBI are best described as:

Correct Answer: A [regulations]

Explanation:

Standards issued by statutory regulators such as SEBI and RBI are regulations, that is, binding rules made under powers given by laws passed by Parliament. Conduct rules, by contrast, govern the behaviour of government employees.

9.  

Penalising a poor first-time offender strictly, or showing leniency, is a dilemma of:

Correct Answer: B [justice versus mercy]

Explanation:

Choosing between strict punishment and leniency for a poor first-time offender is the classic justice-versus-mercy dilemma. Indian law allows mercy in such cases, for example through probation under the Probation of Offenders Act, 1958.

10.  

Consider the following statements:

1. Laws may lag behind new ethical problems.
2. Conscience can be biased or mistaken.
3. A serving official should practise civil disobedience against orders he or she dislikes.

Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

Correct Answer: B [1 and 2 only]

Explanation:

Statements 1 and 2 are correct: laws can lag behind new ethical problems, and conscience can be biased or mistaken. Statement 3 is wrong because a serving official should dissent through lawful channels, such as recording objections, and not through civil disobedience.

11.  

Assertion (A): "Following orders" is not a valid defence for clearly unlawful acts by officials.

Reason (R): Officials remain morally and legally responsible for acts they carry out.

Correct Answer: A [Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A]

Explanation:

Both statements are true and R explains A: officials remain morally and legally responsible for their own acts, so 'following orders' cannot excuse clearly unlawful acts. The Nuremberg trials after the Second World War firmly rejected the defence of superior orders.

12.  

Reporting a senior colleague's wrongdoing despite personal ties is a dilemma of:

Correct Answer: C [truth versus loyalty]

Explanation:

Reporting a close senior's wrongdoing pits honesty against personal ties, which is the truth-versus-loyalty dilemma. Loyalty in public service is owed first to the Constitution and the public, not to individuals.

13.  

Which of the following is the last resort for an official facing a severe crisis of conscience?

Correct Answer: C [Resignation]

Explanation:

Recording dissent, seeking written orders and referring the matter upward come first, so resignation is the last resort in a severe crisis of conscience. Resigning too early also removes an honest official from the system where they could correct wrongs.

14.  

The Whistle Blowers Protection Act was enacted in:

Correct Answer: D [2014]

Explanation:

The Whistle Blowers Protection Act was enacted in 2014 to protect people who expose corruption by public servants. The RTI Act dates from 2005 and the Lokpal and Lokayuktas Act from 2013.

15.  

In private institutions, the main loyalty conflict is often between:

Correct Answer: C [shareholders and wider stakeholders]

Explanation:

In private firms, the key loyalty conflict is between profit for shareholders and duties to wider stakeholders such as employees, consumers and society. Conflicts between ministers and civil servants or between the Centre and the States belong to the public sector, not private institutions.

16.  

Acquiring one family's land for a public hospital is an example of the dilemma of:

Correct Answer: B [individual versus community]

Explanation:

Taking one family's land for a hospital that serves many people is the individual-versus-community dilemma. Fair compensation and rehabilitation under the Right to Fair Compensation (LARR) Act, 2013 help balance the family's loss against the public need.

17.  

Arrange the following in chronological order:

1. Public Interest Disclosure Resolution
2. Whistle Blowers Protection Act
3. Thoreau's Civil Disobedience
4. Bijoe Emmanuel judgment

Select the correct answer using the code given below:

Correct Answer: C [3-4-1-2]

Explanation:

Thoreau's essay Civil Disobedience appeared in 1849, the Bijoe Emmanuel judgment in 1986, the Public Interest Disclosure and Protection of Informers (PIDPI) Resolution in 2004 and the Whistle Blowers Protection Act in 2014, giving 3-4-1-2. In Bijoe Emmanuel the Supreme Court protected students who stood respectfully but did not sing the national anthem on grounds of faith.

18.  

Which of the following is the first step in resolving an ethical dilemma?

Correct Answer: D [Recognising the dilemma and the values in conflict]

Explanation:

Resolving an ethical dilemma starts with recognising that a dilemma exists and naming the values in conflict. Only then can one gather facts, weigh options and choose; deciding in haste or simply following a senior's wish skips this reasoning.

19.  

The weakness of regulations as a source of ethical guidance includes the risk of:

Correct Answer: D [capture by the industry being regulated]

Explanation:

Regulations carry the risk of regulatory capture, where the regulator ends up serving the industry it regulates instead of the public. The idea was developed by economist George Stigler, and it is countered by transparency, cooling-off periods and independent regulators.

20.  

Laws and rules, as a source of ethical guidance, mainly provide:

Correct Answer: A [minimum standards that can be enforced]

Explanation:

Laws set enforceable minimum standards; ethics often demands more, and laws may lag behind new moral problems.

➤ Concepts, thinkers, Indian administrative examples and solved case studies with model-answer outlines for GS Paper IV – U21 · Ethics, Integrity and Aptitude (UPSC book, ₹249): www.shanmugamiasacademy.in/study-materials/upsc-ethics-integrity-aptitude

📘 U21 · Ethics, Integrity and Aptitude – UPSC Civil Services (Mains GS Paper IV)
Here you get the answer with a one-line explanation. 20 chapters · 51 case studies (27 solved, 24 practice) · 119 Mains questions with full model-answer outlines + UPSC GS-IV PYQs · thinker tables, revision cards
Get the book – ₹249 ₹499 →
More quizzes
› UPSC Ethics, Integrity and Aptitude – Chapter 20: Case Studies – Approach, Solution Framework and Solved Examples (19 MCQs) › UPSC Ethics, Integrity and Aptitude – Chapter 19: Work Culture, Service Delivery, Utilisation of Public Funds and Challenges of Corruption (20 MCQs) › UPSC Ethics, Integrity and Aptitude – Chapter 18: Transparency, Right to Information, Codes of Ethics and Conduct, and Citizen's Charters (19 MCQs) › UPSC Ethics, Integrity and Aptitude – Chapter 17: Probity in Governance – Concept of Public Service and Philosophical Basis (19 MCQs) › UPSC Ethics, Integrity and Aptitude – Chapter 16: Ethical Issues in International Relations and Funding; Corporate Governance (21 MCQs) › UPSC Ethics, Integrity and Aptitude – Chapter 15: Accountability, Ethical Governance and Strengthening Ethical Values in Governance (20 MCQs)
Score: 0 Answered: 0 / 0