UPSC Ethics, Integrity and Aptitude – Chapter 20: Case Studies – Approach, Solution Framework and Solved Examples (19 MCQs)

← Back

UPSC Ethics, Integrity and Aptitude – Chapter 20: Case Studies – Approach, Solution Framework and Solved Examples (19 MCQs) – 11 questions, subject: Ethics (GS-IV). Every question has the correct answer with a two-line explanation; tap "Show Answer". Free practice for TNPSC, UPSC, SSC, Bank and RRB exams – Shanmugam IAS Academy, Coimbatore.

Get daily current affairs & exam alerts – follow us YouTube WhatsApp Channel Telegram Channel Facebook Page Instagram
Share with friends & study groups
Link to this page from your website / blog (HTML code)
1.  

Among stakeholders, a strong answer usually lists first:

Correct Answer: C [the vulnerable and directly affected]

Explanation:

A strong answer lists the vulnerable and directly affected stakeholders first, since their rights and welfare are most at stake. Superiors, the media and the officer's own family are secondary stakeholders whose interests come after the public interest.

2.  

Which of the following is the best initial response to an oral order to do something illegal?

Correct Answer: A [Seek written orders and point out the legal position]

Explanation:

Facing an illegal oral order, an official should first point out the legal position and ask for the order in writing. Obeying silently makes the official a party to the illegality, while resigning or leaking to the media are not the proper first steps.

3.  

A district faces rampant illegal sand mining. The most sustainable long-term step is a:

Correct Answer: B [district sand mining plan with legal supply]

Explanation:

Illegal sand mining is curbed in the long term by a district survey-based sand mining plan that creates a legal, regulated supply. One-off raids or transfers give only short relief, and a total construction ban would be impractical and harmful.

4.  

An officer managing a crowd of stranded migrant workers must be guided, alongside public order, by:

Correct Answer: B [compassion and dignity]

Explanation:

Handling stranded migrant workers calls for compassion and respect for their dignity, alongside maintaining public order. Article 21 protects the right to live with dignity, and the 2020 lockdown showed that food, shelter and safe transport calm a crowd better than force.

5.  

Consider the following statements about strong case-study answers:

1. They give three or four realistic options with merits and demerits.
2. They end with a long-term systemic measure.
3. They begin by repeating the full case.

Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

Correct Answer: B [1 and 2 only]

Explanation:

Statements 1 and 2 are correct: strong answers weigh three or four realistic options with merits and demerits and end with a long-term systemic measure. Statement 3 is wrong because the case should only be summarised briefly, as repeating it wastes time and words.

6.  

Assertion (A): Automated decisions that cancel welfare benefits should allow a hearing before cancellation.

Reason (R): Due process protects genuine beneficiaries from errors in data or software.

Correct Answer: A [Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A]

Explanation:

Both statements are true and R explains A: errors in data or software can wrongly cancel benefits, so due process requires a hearing before cancellation. The principle of natural justice 'audi alteram partem' (hear the other side) applies to automated decisions as much as to human ones.

7.  

Gram sabha consent in forest areas is required mainly under the:

Correct Answer: B [Forest Rights Act, 2006]

Explanation:

The Forest Rights Act, 2006 makes the gram sabha the authority to determine forest rights, and its consent is needed before forest land is diverted. In the Niyamgiri case (2013) the Supreme Court left the decision on bauxite mining to the gram sabhas under this Act.

8.  

Which of the following is a fault to avoid in case answers?

Correct Answer: D [Writing a moral sermon instead of steps]

Explanation:

Examiners expect practical, numbered action steps grounded in clear values, so writing a moral sermon instead of steps is the fault to avoid. Naming values, giving steps and suggesting long-term reforms are all features of a good case-study answer.

9.  

An employee finds that her company has falsified drug-trial data. Her dilemma is best named as:

Correct Answer: B [truth versus loyalty]

Explanation:

Exposing falsified drug-trial data clashes with loyalty to one's employer and colleagues, so it is a classic truth-versus-loyalty dilemma. Public health depends on honest trial data, which is why honesty and integrity must prevail over misplaced loyalty.

10.  

Arrange the following laws in chronological order:

1. POSH Act
2. Whistle Blowers Protection Act
3. Forest Rights Act
4. Disaster Management Act

Select the correct answer using the code given below:

Correct Answer: C [4-3-1-2]

Explanation:

The Disaster Management Act came in 2005, the Forest Rights Act in 2006, the POSH Act in 2013 and the Whistle Blowers Protection Act in 2014, giving the order 4-3-1-2. Option (a) is wrong because the Forest Rights Act came after the Disaster Management Act, not before it.

11.  

In an emergency where lives are at risk, the right order of action for an officer is:

Correct Answer: A [acting humanely first and recording soon after]

Explanation:

In an emergency, the official acts humanely first to save lives and records the reasons soon after.

➤ Concepts, thinkers, Indian administrative examples and solved case studies with model-answer outlines for GS Paper IV – U21 · Ethics, Integrity and Aptitude (UPSC book, ₹249): www.shanmugamiasacademy.in/study-materials/upsc-ethics-integrity-aptitude

📘 U21 · Ethics, Integrity and Aptitude – UPSC Civil Services (Mains GS Paper IV)
Here you get the answer with a one-line explanation. 20 chapters · 51 case studies (27 solved, 24 practice) · 119 Mains questions with full model-answer outlines + UPSC GS-IV PYQs · thinker tables, revision cards
Get the book – ₹249 ₹499 →
More quizzes
› UPSC Ethics, Integrity and Aptitude – Chapter 19: Work Culture, Service Delivery, Utilisation of Public Funds and Challenges of Corruption (20 MCQs) › UPSC Ethics, Integrity and Aptitude – Chapter 18: Transparency, Right to Information, Codes of Ethics and Conduct, and Citizen's Charters (19 MCQs) › UPSC Ethics, Integrity and Aptitude – Chapter 17: Probity in Governance – Concept of Public Service and Philosophical Basis (19 MCQs) › UPSC Ethics, Integrity and Aptitude – Chapter 16: Ethical Issues in International Relations and Funding; Corporate Governance (21 MCQs) › UPSC Ethics, Integrity and Aptitude – Chapter 15: Accountability, Ethical Governance and Strengthening Ethical Values in Governance (20 MCQs) › UPSC Ethics, Integrity and Aptitude – Chapter 14: Ethical Dilemmas and Sources of Ethical Guidance – Laws, Rules, Regulations and Conscience (20 MCQs)
Score: 0 Answered: 0 / 0